I think this is an easily solvable case. My Columbo-like mind reasons that if the police just track grocery store sales of Buffalo Bleu Cheese Dipping sauce ingredients, they'll be able to find out where this SUPER, SUPERBOWL party is taking place!
"We got ya'. No one eats that many vegetables on Superbowl Sunday unless you're making dipping sauce for $65,000 (worth) of chicken wings."
Or as our friend Yulandist says:
"I just get enough to season it,
and cook it up when I need it."
That philosophy sure would have kept those dudes outta trouble! (-;